Every city on the SF Peninsula protects trees. But the rules vary widely. A eucalyptus that needs no permit in Atherton can cost up to $5,000 per tree, or the tree's value, in Menlo Park. After 13 years in arboriculture across all of these cities, the most expensive mistake I see is assuming the rules in one city match the city next door.
This guide covers 6 Peninsula cities: Palo Alto, San Mateo, Redwood City, Menlo Park, Burlingame, and Atherton. For San Carlos, see its city page. Each city has its own ordinance, its own thresholds, and its own enforcement culture. If you are unsure whether a tree on your property qualifies as a heritage tree, professional assessment and documentation can clarify your obligations and options.
Key Takeaways
- Every Peninsula city here has a tree protection ordinance. Thresholds range from 31.4 inches circumference for oaks in Menlo Park and San Mateo to 48 inches in Atherton; Palo Alto protects coast redwoods only from 18 inches diameter
- Penalties for unpermitted removal reach $10,000 per tree or twice reproduction cost in Palo Alto, and up to $10,000 per participant per tree in San Mateo
- Menlo Park protects native oaks at 10 inches diameter and fines up to $5,000 per tree, or the tree's value, whichever is higher
- Palo Alto protects six native species at 11.5 inches diameter, coast redwoods at 18 inches, and most other species at 15 inches
- Burlingame's in-lieu fee is $325 per inch of trunk diameter when a removed protected tree is not replanted on site
- If you're remodeling near a protected tree, budget for a tree protection plan from a certified arborist
The Quick Comparison
Here's the cheat sheet. See the 56-city ordinance table for a full overview, the interactive map for a visual comparison, or scroll down for the full breakdown of each city.
| City | Protected Size | Key Threshold | Max Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Palo Alto | 11.5″ dia. (six natives) / 15″ (most other species) / 18″ (coast redwood) | Three size tiers; measured at 54″ | $10,000 per tree or 2× reproduction cost, whichever higher |
| San Mateo | 10″ dia. (oaks) / 15″ dia. (all other species) | Oaks at 31.4″ circ.; others at 47.1″ circ. | Up to $10,000 per participant per tree |
| Redwood City | 38″ circ. (about 12.1″ dia.) | All species; measured at widest point 6″ to 36″ above ground | $500 per tree + replacement equal to appraised value |
| Menlo Park | 47.1″ circ. (15″ dia.) / native oaks 31.4″ (10″ dia.) | Report from city-approved arborist required | Up to $5,000 per tree or tree value, whichever higher |
| Burlingame | 44″ circ. (14″ dia.) | All species, single threshold; in-lieu fee $325 per inch | Up to $1,000 per violation + restitution |
| Atherton | 48″ circ. (15.2″ dia.) | Oaks anywhere on lot; other species only outside main buildable area | Removal: 2× appraised value; damage: ½ appraised value |
Five of these cities measure at 54 inches above grade. Redwood City measures at the widest point between 6 and 36 inches. Use our Permit Checker to see if your tree likely needs a permit.
City-by-City Breakdown
Palo Alto : Three Size Tiers
Palo Alto's Protected Tree Ordinance (Title 8, Chapter 8.10) uses three size tiers. Six native species (bigleaf maple, California incense cedar, coast live oak, blue oak, California black oak, and valley oak) are protected at 11.5 inches diameter. Coast redwoods are protected at 18 inches. All other non-invasive, non-high-water-use species are protected at 15 inches. Diameter is measured at 54 inches above natural grade.
Invasive and high-water-use species are not protected. Most other species are protected once they reach 15 inches in diameter. A 12-inch-diameter coast live oak is protected; a 12-inch liquidambar is not.
Violations are steep: $10,000 per tree or twice the tree's CTLA reproduction cost, whichever is higher. The city also requires replacement at twice the prescribed ratio and can impose a development moratorium of up to 5 years.
Pro tip: Every protected tree removal permit is decided on a report from a designated arborist. Hazard claims need a Level 2 TRAQ assessment, and pruning a protected tree requires a 7-day posted notice.
San Mateo : Two Thresholds
San Mateo's Heritage Tree Ordinance (Municipal Code 13.40) protects oaks (Quercus) at 10 inches diameter (31.4 inches circumference) and any other species at 15 inches diameter (47.1 inches circumference), measured at 54 inches above natural grade. Street trees need a permit for any pruning or removal.
This means your Italian stone pine , your liquidambar, even that eucalyptus you've wanted to remove for years: at 15 inches diameter, you need a permit. Private protected tree removals are filed through Community Development (Building intake, 650-522-7172). Street and heritage tree permits go through the Parks and Recreation Tree Division (650-522-7420).
Civil penalties run up to $10,000 per participant per tree. Unpermitted removals must be replaced with a 48-inch box tree (FY 2026-27 cost $3,376), or more, up to the tree's replacement value. Dead trees get no expedited track; dead is an approval criterion, and a 15-gallon replacement is still owed.
Pro tip: San Mateo has an active urban forestry program. If you're not sure whether your tree qualifies, call the city arborist. Staff are generally helpful, and asking is far cheaper than finding out the hard way.
Redwood City : Two Separate Programs
Redwood City runs two parallel tree protection programs that sometimes confuse homeowners. The protected tree rules (Municipal Code Chapter 35) cover any species at 38 inches circumference (about 12.1 inches diameter), measured at the widest point between 6 and 36 inches above ground. Heritage trees designated by the Park and Recreation Commission are protected at any size. Separately, street trees in the public right-of-way are covered regardless of size.
Protected tree removal permits are free, require an arborist report, and are normally processed within ten working days. Pruning a protected tree also needs a free permit. Street tree work goes through Public Works (650-780-7464).
Unpermitted removal or pruning costs $500 per tree plus replacement equal to the appraised value of the original tree, with possible misdemeanor charges. A dead or dying tree is an approval ground, not an exemption; the free permit is still required. In a true emergency, remove the tree and contact the City Arborist within 72 hours for inspection and an after-the-fact permit.
Pro tip: If you're buying property in Redwood City, get a tree survey before closing. Heritage trees near the building envelope can significantly affect what you can build and where.
Menlo Park : Low Oak Threshold
Menlo Park's Heritage Tree Ordinance (Municipal Code Chapter 13.24) protects any non-oak tree at 47.1 inches circumference (15 inches diameter). Native California oaks are protected at just 31.4 inches (10 inches diameter), measured at 54 inches above natural grade. That catches a lot of trees.
Two things stand out. First, the city maintains an approved consulting arborist list and every removal or significant-pruning application needs a report from that list, written within the last 12 months. If the tree is dead or an invasive species, photos can be submitted in place of the report. Second, only the applicant may appeal a decision, to the City Manager within 15 days. Homeowner cases get no neighbor notice.
Violations cost up to $5,000 per tree or the tree's value, whichever is higher, plus replacement per the city's trunk-diameter matrix or an in-lieu payment to the heritage tree fund. The permit fee is $542 per tree for the first three trees and $270 for each additional tree (FY 2026-27).
Pro tip: Before hiring an arborist for a Menlo Park heritage tree report, confirm they are on the city's approved list. The City Arborist's heritage permit line is (650) 330-6764.
Burlingame : Single Threshold, Per-Inch In-Lieu Fee
Burlingame's Urban Reforestation and Tree Protection Ordinance (Chapter 11.06) protects every species at a single threshold: 44 inches circumference (about 14 inches diameter), measured at 54 inches. There is no separate oak tier.
If you're approved for a removal but can't replant on site, the in-lieu fee is $325 per inch of trunk diameter (FY 2026-27). The residential application fee is $462, or $158 without public notification; commercial is $779. Unpermitted removal is a misdemeanor or infraction of up to $1,000 per violation, with each tree and each day counted separately, plus restitution: a replacement tree or the appraised value plus replacement costs.
Emergency removal is allowed only by order of the Parks and Recreation Director or designated emergency personnel, and ordered removals must be completed within 7 days. There is no remove-first option. The Parks Division arborist line is (650) 558-7330.
Burlingame has been a Tree City USA since 1980. The Howard-Ralston Eucalyptus Tree Rows along El Camino Real are on the National Register of Historic Places (listed 2012, trees 130+ years old).
Pro tip: Burlingame's hillside properties are especially tricky. Many have both heritage trees and steep slope requirements. Get your tree assessment done before you hire an architect, not after.
Atherton : Builder-Friendly, Except for Oaks
Atherton is the outlier on the Peninsula. Non-oak trees inside the main buildable area do not need a permit. Eucalyptus, acacias, tree of heaven, mimosa, and Monterey pine are exempt at any size (Ordinance 679, 2026). But there's one big exception: valley, coast live, and blue oaks at 48 inches circumference are protected anywhere on the lot.
Other species are protected at 48 inches circumference (15.2 inches diameter) only outside the main buildable area. Dead or dangerous trees are approved at staff level after a Town Arborist inspection; other removals go to the Planning Commission. FY 2026-27 fees are $775 for the first tree plus $265 for each additional tree at staff level, and $7,310 for a Planning Commission-level removal. Planning Commission applications must include a tree survey and arborist report.
Where Atherton gets expensive is violations. Unpermitted removal costs twice the appraised value of the tree. Damage costs half the appraised value, rising to twice if the tree dies within a year. On estate-scale Atherton lots, mature oaks carry high appraised values.
A permit is required before removal even for dead or dangerous trees; retroactive permits exist only as a violation remedy. The Town Arborist can be reached at (650) 752-0526.
Pro tip: If you're purchasing property in Atherton, invest $1,500 to $3,000 in a pre-purchase arborist assessment. A single protected oak in the wrong location can eliminate a building pad or add $50,000+ to construction costs for root zone protection.
What Homeowners Get Wrong Most Often
⚠️ "My neighbor removed a similar tree, so I can too."
Every tree is evaluated individually. Your neighbor may have gotten a permit you didn't know about, or their tree may have been a different species, or their project may have predated the current ordinance. Assuming your situation is the same is the most common way homeowners end up with violation notices.
⚠️ "The tree is dead, so I don't need a permit."
In most Peninsula cities, you still need a permit to remove a dead heritage tree. The process is usually faster and approval is nearly guaranteed, but skipping it can still trigger fines. Some cities require an arborist letter confirming the tree is dead or hazardous before they'll issue a removal permit.
⚠️ "I'll just prune it way back instead of removing it."
Several Peninsula cities regulate pruning too. San Mateo treats pruning of more than 25 percent of the crown as major pruning. Redwood City requires a free permit to prune a protected tree, and Menlo Park requires a permit for significant pruning. Palo Alto requires a 7-day posted notice before pruning a protected tree. This trap catches a lot of homeowners.
How to Check If Your Tree Is Protected
Start with our free Permit Checker . Enter your zip code, tree species, and size, and it will tell you whether a permit is likely required in your city.
For anything complex (construction near protected trees, multi-tree removals, disputed species identification), hire a consulting arborist who knows your specific city's ordinance.
Not Sure About Your Tree?
Check your city's rules, or request a consultation on a specific tree.
For one city's rules in depth, see Los Altos Heritage Trees & the 12-Inch Rule, including the 10-inch native species threshold and real penalty scenarios.

